Does Brown Sugar Go Bad? How Long Do They Last?

logo by Editorial Staff | Updated on August 3rd, 2022

Brown sugar doesn’t go bad if it’s kept well wrapped in a cold, dry area.

After a while, it may begin to clump, but this is not a symptom of spoiling, and hardened brown sugar is readily repaired.

Of course, brown sugar’s flavor and general quality deteriorate over time, but it’s usually safe to use much past the “expiration” date.

Interested in learning more about clumped brown sugar storage, shelf life, deterioration indications, and softening?

Is it possible for brown sugar to spoil?

No. Brown sugar, like other varieties of sugar, may be stored indefinitely as long as it is not exposed to air or moisture and pests are kept at bay.

After opening, some manufacturers insert a two-year best-before date. Brown sugar will not get rancid after two years, although the flavor and texture will vary somewhat. Brown sugar may only deteriorate if it becomes polluted owing to incorrect storage.

The same holds for various forms of sugar, such as white and powdered sugar.

That being said, there are a few occasions when you should dump your brown sugar and buy a new bag. Let’s go into it.

What is the shelf life of brown sugar?

Brown sugar has a two-year shelf life, although it may be stored indefinitely if insects and water are kept out of the container.

Those two years approximate how long brown sugar will keep its best quality. And the conclusion of that time is indicated by the date printed on the label, which is usually designated “best-by” or “best-if-used-by.”

That is not an “expiration date,” and it is about quality rather than food safety. In other words, brown sugar keeps far past the expiration date written on the label.

If your brown sugar has been in storage for a few years, it may not be the greatest (in terms of quality), but the taste change will be modest at best.

Although it is at its finest after two years, brown sugar may be stored indefinitely and can even be recovered if it turns hard. Brown sugar has a shelf life determined by the best before date and how the brown sugar is stored.

Past Printed Date
Brown Sugar lasts forIndefinite, but Best within 2 Years
Sugar lasts forIndefinite – see our sugar page for full information on cane sugar, raw sugar, and confectioner sugar.

*A word of caution concerning expiry dates…

Although the Brown Sugar shelf life information on Eat By Date is generally valid, please keep in mind that individual circumstances will differ and that our advice should only be regarded as an opinion and not a substitute for the advice of your health care expert. Please eat with caution!

How Can You Tell If Brown Sugar Is Bad?

When determining whether or not your brown sugar is safe to use, look for the following:

  • In the package, there may be dead (or living) insects, larvae, or eggs. They occasionally make their way into the container or bag, indicating that the product is no longer safe to eat.
  • Mold or any other type of organic development If water got into the packaging and there was mold or other organic growth, the sugar was ruined.

Those are the common indicators of brown sugar deterioration; if you see one of them, throw away the sugar.

However, there are also additional warning indicators that you should be aware of. Examples include:

  • Sugar has clumped together. Brown sugar has more moisture than white sugar, and when the moisture evaporates, the sugar hardens. It’s a normal response, and the sugar may still be consumed. In the next section, I discuss numerous methods for softening brown sugar.
  • Sugar has an unpleasant odor. Sugar absorbs other fragrances, so if yours smells like one of the things you keep, your brown sugar likely acquired that odor. That also implies that the bag or container isn’t properly sealed. If the odor it emits is overpowering, it’s better to eliminate it. Otherwise, your baked items will absorb part of the odor, which is undesirable.

If you don’t have brown sugar, you may create your own by combining 1 tablespoon molasses and 1 cup white granulated sugar. After giving this mixture a thorough stir, your homemade brown sugar is ready to use.

When prepared in a dish, how long does Brown Sugar last?

What is the shelf life of brown sugar? Is it possible for brown sugar to spoil? That is conditional. What is the shelf life of cookies? Brown sugar, in general, is one of the last expiring components in any meal, although it nevertheless expires along with the substances with which it is blended.

What Is the Best Way to Soften Hard Brown Sugar?

If brown sugar is stored for an extended amount of time or is not well sealed, it will dry up and develop clumps.

While hardened brown sugar is not damaged, it is nearly difficult to use. And it’s for this reason that you want to soften it.

Fortunately, softening clumped brown sugar is simple. There are two approaches you may take.

Brown Sugar Loosening by Hand

There are several methods for manually softening clumped brown sugar. Some of the most well-known examples are:

  • chopping it up with a fork
  • placing the clumps in a bag and slamming them against a wall 
  • counter with an electric mixer or a blender

The concept is the same for all of them: you apply physical force to separate the clumps. The biggest advantage is that they operate instantly – you get brown sugar granules ready to use right away.

Bringing Back the Moisture in Clumped Brown Sugar

This is about finding a new moisture supply for brown sugar molasses. There are two possibilities here:

  • Fill the jar with an apple wedge, a slice of fresh bread, orange peel, or a few marshmallows. Brown sugar will gradually absorb moisture from either of these items and soften. The process takes at least a couple of hours to complete (it is not a quick repair).
  • Cover the sugar with a little moist paper towel and microwave on high for 30 seconds, checking every 30 seconds. If you don’t have a microwave, an oven will suffice. Please remember that the sugar will harden as it cools, so take as much as you need immediately away.

Softening by providing a fresh supply of moisture to the sugar is preferable since it tackles the underlying problem. Its biggest disadvantage is that it takes some time, which is inconvenient if you need brown sugar straight away.

When should you be concerned about using brown sugar?

We’ve already discussed the benefits of brown sugar, such as its great lifespan and immortality in normal conditions. Nonetheless, its seductive sweetness makes it more vulnerable to pest infection. Ants and other creatures, like humans, are drawn to the sweetness.

As a result, insect contamination is the most prevalent occurrence, especially if the sugar is not stored in an insulated container. If you see bugs in the sugar, you should be concerned; in that case, it’s best to trash it rather than consuming it.

While this does not necessarily suggest that the sugar has been tainted, the bugs may transmit illnesses and bacteria. To avoid this destiny, we recommend that you store the sugar in an airtight container.

How should you store brown sugar?

Brown sugar may be stored properly and utilized for many years. While it is commonly stored in a pantry, the placement may not be best for brown sugar storage. As a result, we’ve compiled a list of methods for safely storing it and keeping it from spoiling.

Check that the storage space is cool and dry.

Brown sugar should be kept in a temperature-controlled environment. Remember that high temperatures destroy the texture of brown sugar. While this does not necessarily render it harmful for ingestion, the brown sugar does become ugly.

When we say cold, we don’t mean keep the sugar in your mini-fridge or counter-depth refrigerator. When combined with moisture, the cool temperature inside a refrigerator will dramatically harden the sugar.

Brown sugar is commonly stored in cabinets, pantries, or just convenient locations in the kitchen. When storing sugar in your kitchen, keep it away from your induction range or oven, as this may cause the sugar’s texture to deform.

Also, keep the sugar away from water. Sugar builds bonds as an effective moisture absorber, resulting in huge clusters. However, this does not mean that the sugar has gone bad, but simply that correctly combining it becomes difficult.

Sealed bags or insulated containers should be used.

The best situation is not to open the brown sugar container right away. However, if you’ve opened it, you must place the sugar in a zippered bag or an insulated and airtight container away from pests.

If air becomes trapped in the container, the sugar hardens because it may absorb a lot of moisture from the air. As a result, employing the hardened form can be difficult because it’s a delicious substance often contaminated by a slew of creatures, including moths, ants, moths, and flies.

Most of the time, contamination by these animals is the primary cause of brown sugar spoilage. As a result, putting it in an airtight container or plastic bag can make all the difference in keeping it safe for years to come.


Editorial Staff

Our writers, editors, content managers, and SEO specialist. We all take part in crafting amazing articles. We spend hours ensuring that each article is based on facts, researched, and thorough. You'll never want to click the back button to look for more answers other than here!